Sitting in the tech booth during a service on a recent Sunday, I had an "a-ha" moment. Not a big one, but still a good lesson.
We had traded worship bands for the day with our sister church. Our band was playing at their place, and vice versa.
One of our front of house people, Justin, traveled with the band to do the mixing. Just as our service began, I received a text from Justin that simply said, "Running a service at 85 dBA. A new record!" I glanced over at the Smaart app running on my iPad, and our levels were hovering around 88 dBA.
This was during a mellow song; moments later we were doing 90 to 95 dBA. Just then, Justin texted me again: "Update. I was able to get it to 80 dBA. It seems to have pleased the masses."
This "conversation" (via text) got me thinking about the "how loud is too loud"conversation that's a constant among church tech folks.
I realized this:
1) Since we've installed a new loudspeaker system and acoustical treatment, we've been running a bit louder yet haven't received a single complaint (or for that matter, even a "suggestion" to turn it down).
2) Dynamics really do play into perceived level.
We all know that if the sound is pleasing, we tolerate more level. Think of your morning alarm clock at 90 dBA versus your favorite song on the car radio at 90 dBAit's a BIG difference in how you react to those sounds.
Watching as our meter hit 97 dBA, I thought "wow, it just doesn't seem that loud." Clearly, it was a combination of a good mix, excellent system, and the acoustical tightness of the room. (Lends credence to getting the the best system you can and mixing it loud!)
But the "a-ha" moment occurred when the band played a familiar song in a very different way. It usually starts out loud with a big guitar riff and big drums. However, this band began it with acoustic guitar only. I glanced at the meter and it read 72 dBA, and the sound was good and the level "felt" appropriate.
Then without warning came a huge downbeat, with everyone hitting it hard and then taking off. But the meter read just 86 dBA. What?! It had to be wrong, because it sure sounded like 92 to 95 dB.
The answer is obvious, however. The contrast was so great that the perceived change in volume was greater than the actual change. Kind of like when you walk out of a dark space directly into sunlightonce your eyes adjust, it's not usually painfully bright.
The band used this type of dynamic very effectively throughout the service, bringing it way down for the quiet parts and then jumping on louder passages. They were quite skilled at it, and the new system was able to reproduce it very well.
When things got quiet, it still sounded full and rich, and when things got louder, the system responded accurately and without compressing or distorting. I watched the front of house mixer, Trevor, keep his right hand on the control group that we call program (basically everything but vocals). He wasn't shy about riding the control group to also help accentuate the band's change in dynamics.
So the lesson is clear: give dynamics more credence to add power and emotion to the mix.
I realize these observations aren't earth shattering, but it's a valuable reminder to mix to the appropriate level for the sound system. Don't push it if the system can't handle it. Also make sure that the system has enough headroom so that it can respond to these types of changes in level.
It's also vital for us to bear in mind how we can best help accentuate the dynamics that a band is already producing on stage, to take advantage of that while resisting the temptation to overmix and overprocess.
Loud where it should be, soft where it should beuse the dynamics to make it all the more powerful.
Gary Zandstra is a professional AV systems integrator with Parkway Electric and has been involved with sound at his church for more than 30 years. Read more from Gary at garyzandstra.com. This article courtesy of ProSoundWeb Church Sound. It also appeared on Worship TechDecisions.