Is it really an absolute necessity to update or renovate my 15-year-old building?
The working life of a building can and should extend well beyond 50 years, and I've personally seen buildings hundreds of years old still in use and functioning quite well.
The question deserves considerable thought, and begs a slew of additional questions:
1. Has your programming changed (are you doing more youth or children events, etc..)
One of the biggest pressure a growing church faces is space. As the ministry grows there needs to be a place where people can congregate, infants can be cared for, children trained and youth challenged. Sunday is the crunch day. As a culture, we have been conditioned that Sunday is the day where we as Christians head to church for a worship service and education. Also, as a culture Sunday morning has become our social connection time.
When we come to church we often find ourselves getting a cup of coffee and connecting with friends that we just do not have the time or do not make the opportunity to connect with during the week. The church has used many names to refer to this connection space. Whether you call it a narthex, lobby or gather place, this space has become a very important part of a church. Traditionally this space was not given the importance that it is today, so you may find the need to expand, re-arrange or renovate to accommodate the social time that takes place before and after services.
Has your ministry experienced growth in a specific area of ministry? Do you have far more infants in the nursery than in years past? Is your youth ministry rapidly growing? What about the food pantry? I believe that a growing church is almost always in the reuse, renovation or expansion process. A church that is growing is most likely engaging in culture and as culture changes, ministry changes and therefore facility needs change.
2. Are you filling up the sanctuary to more than 80% of its capacity?
The "80% rule" is commonly thrown around. The "rule" is that if you are more than 80% full seating wise you are full.
The logic behind the "rule" is that if the space feels to full, guests and visitors might feel like there is not a place for them. So, what happens when you hit 80% do you add another service?
Do you set up a satellite overflow room? I have mixed feelings about the 80% rule. Millennials will more quickly spend money for an experience and thus I believe they are attending church for an experience. Does a full sanctuary give them the rich experience they are looking for?
Millennials also long for intimacy and connection so would a smaller venue serve them better? What about the rest of the congregation, what are their preferences? There is not a right over arching answer here, However, there is a right answer for your congregation. My suggestion is to be aware of the 80% rule and make decisions with that knowledge in hand.
3. Does your building look dated?
By dated we are not talking about a neo-classical or some other look that is time-less. What I am referring to is the purple, mauve other dated colors from the previous few decades. I also want to differentiate from dated vs not kept up.
Dated means it is out of style. It doesn't mean that there are tears in the carpet, chips in the walls or dust covering the kickplate on the walls. Those things are things that are not kept up or cared for. Something that is not kept up is not acceptable in any style décor.
When I visit with churches that have that dated look, I think to myself why do they not just refresh the paint and change out a little bit of furniture? The cost would be minimal and the impact would be great. What I have come to realize is that people who attend the church on a steady basis do not even notice it. It is just like your home you become accustom to it and do not even notice what it looks like.
I suggest that you find the person in the church that has "the eye" for design and have them take a fresh look at your space and give some ideas. If there is not someone in the congregation, hire an interior designer and give them clear direction as to what you are wanting to accomplish and the budget that you plan to spend on improvements.
4. Has the expectation of your congregation changed?
If you say no to this question you are most likely not in a church that has engaged modern culture. Expectation are always changing. Just think how technology has change our expectations. We expect immediate response and answers.
Thanks to amazon prime we expect it in 2 days without shipping charges. As culture changes expectations definitely change. Let's go back to the discussion above on the Lobby.
In previous generations people were regularly engaged and connected to their neighbors and surrounding community.
Church was just one of the many places that people would see each other and have meaningful conversation and connection with each other. Today church is often the only spot where we connect with people and stop and talk rather than just saying a quick "hi" as we pass each other.
5. What is the expectation of people who come and visit your church?
A big red flag here if you do not know at least something about the expectations of the people that visit your church. Unfortunately, most people who visit have low or wrong expectations based on their history or exposure to church. In this case I believe it is the churches responsibility to blow up and change the expectations.
Shouldn't people have an expectation when they come to visit your church of finding a warm, well cared for functional building filled with warm welcoming people?
Is it necessary to update or renovate a building every 15 years? My take as I stated above is that you should always be renovating, updating, changing and/or expanding. Doing this on a consistent basis keeps your facility looking fresh and helps to support the ministry areas that are experiencing the most growth.